Article by Kevin J. Weiland, MD, FACP

Close Window   

 


Influenza Vaccine Shortage

The greatest success story in modern medicine has been the use of vaccinations to control and eliminate disease—a tribute to the English physician, Dr. Edward Jenner, who started it all more than 200 years ago.  Immunizations are kin to the “finger in the dyke”, referring to the amount of money spent on the vaccine is considered trivial to the amount of money spent on treating complications of infection. 

Unlike last year’s shortage of vaccine, the Center for Disease Control (CDC) and the State Health Department has assured us of a plentiful supply for this year’s flu season.  The agency has four companies making the vaccine this year, compared to just two in 2004.  Access to the vaccine, however, has not been as plentiful for many rural South Dakota physicians and clinics.

According to one state health official, the makers of the vaccine sent a majority of the supply to their “best customers”, that being the larger retailers.  These retail corporations are able to buy in bulk, (usually at a cheaper price), and administer the vaccine to their customers.  In a two hour period, over 100 people received the shot at a local corporate retail store.  At $25 a shot, they are making a pretty nice profit.

Don’t get me wrong, as a physician, I am pleased to see large corporations offering the vaccine to the general public.  I feel that everyone in the country should be vaccinated.  (The more people vaccinated, the less overall virus circulating in the community.)  What disturbs me is the fact that physicians have a limited supply for their high risk patients, while corporate America can profit from a vaccine that could save our country billions of dollars in health care costs treating complications of the virus in our high risk patients.

Profit may not be the only thing on the minds of the heads of these large corporations, reducing sick time by vaccinating their employees first can save corporate America billions of dollars each year in lost productivity.  Even the State Health Department reserved their vaccine for state employees first, recently turning down several of my Medicare patients seeking a flu shot.

After “9-11”, I was hopeful that our Government would gear up to take on any threat to this country, including infectious disease.  Unfortunately, much of our resources in the fight against terrorism ended up in the wrong place.  Funding further research into efficient ways to produce a vaccine and detect disease quickly has long been under funded and more recently, been cut.  This country must invest in a public health infrastructure, or we will not be able to respond to real public health emergencies. 

The “Katrina of infectious disease” (Avian “bird” flu) may be just around the corner.  And like Katrina, the response by our government to prepare for such a devastating pandemic may be a little too late.

Content of articles can only be used with writer attribution to Dr. Kevin Weiland.
 


 

 

©2006 The Dakota Diet, Dr. Kevin Weiland